Photo's courtesy Archives of the R.C. Archdiocese of Toronto' (ARCAT) and St. Joseph's Parish Archives.
| Rev. John Walsh December 1854 - April 1857 |
| Rev.
John Lee April 1857 - May 1860 | |
| Rev. Louis Braire June 1860 - June 1881 | Rev.
Francis Rohleder June 1886 - May 1891 |
| |
| Rev. Pat Kiernan May 1891 - September 1894 | Rev.
Charles Cantillon September 1894 - September 1900 | ||
| Rev. Michael Cline September 1900 - May 1907 |
| Rev.
James Hayes May 1907 - September 1913 | |
| Rev. Thomas Redmond September 1913 - May 1918 | Rev.
George Prance May 1918 - August 1936 | ||
| Rev. F. J. Flanagan August 1936 - June 1942 |
| Rev.
Thomas Toomey June 1942 - July 1947 |
|
| Rev. Joseph Murphy June 1947 - June 1952 |
| Rev.
Arthur McMahon June 1952 - August 1955 |
|
| Rev. Vincent McGivney August 1955 - October 1956 |
| Rev.
Joseph H. O'Neill October 1956 - June 1964 |
|
| Rev. John Buckley June 1964 - June 1967 |
| Rev.
Thomas J. McManus June 1967 - June 1979 |
|
| Rev. John Moyer June 1979 - October 1980 |
| Rev.
Robert Ouellette October 1980 - April 1985 |
|
| Rev. Francis (Frank) Skumavc April 1985 - June 1997 |
| Rev.
J. Bernard Canning June 1997 - September 1998 |
|
| Rev. Charles Faleiro October 1998 - June 1999 |
| Rev.
Wilfried Lenius June 1999 - June 2010 |
|
Rev.
Oswin Fernandes
|
